:
Cleveland County Sheriff’s Office cold Cases
- Timothy Lynn Thomas Aug. 18, 2009
Thomas left for work around 5 a.m. but never made it out of his driveway. Authorities received the 911 call around 6:30 a.m. He was shot outside of his home at 1226 Mary’s Grove Church Road, Kings Mountain. Robbery didn’t appear to be a motive. Thomas left behind three sons.
- Kimberly Frances Pagano Jan. 30, 2009
Pagano was found shot to death on her bathroom floor inside the trailer she shared with a boyfriend. Her boyfriend told police he returned home to find the trailer burglarized and Pagano dead. she was four months pregnant when she died.
- Ricky Lee Mauney Dec. 15, 2008
Mauney’s body was found shot and lying in the middle of a street. He lived in van on the 2900 block of Philadelphia Church Road, Lawndale. Authorities initially thought the death was a result of a hit-and-run, but a bullet wound changed the direction of the investigation. In 2009, neighbors raised $1,600 for information leading to an arrest and conviction.
- Justin Grant July 21, 2006
Grant’s decomposed body was found in a remote area of Lawndale a week after he went missing. Detectives said Grant was shot repeatedly, and the condition of his body made it unclear which bullet was fatal. a medium-caliber gun was used to kill Grant. He was shot multiple times in the head and once in the chest, according to a medical examiner and autopsy reports.
- Jermaine McCluney and Bonita Shipp April 19, 2002
McCluney and Shipp were found beaten to death at 111 Goodall Drive in Kings Mountain. The case was ruled a double homicide.
- Minnie Lee Brooks Sept. 6, 1997
A mother of six children, Brooks was found dead in the bushes on the side of Metcalf Road. she was 28 years old. a jogger found her body. Brooks was shot in her back, leg and stomach. Brooks, whose family admitted she had a crack cocaine addiction, had been missing for several days.
“no one deserves to die like that,” said Brenda Wimbush, Brooks’ sister.
- Sept. 26, 1993
Porter was working a N.C. Department of Transportation job at a rest area near Kings Mountain when he was found tied up, shot in the chest and stuffed inside a utility room. The DOT demolished the site where Charles was found dead a few years ago.
- Judith McMurray April 26, 1993
The victim worked at Penstar Mobile Home Sales on U.S. 74, formerly across from big Lots. Her husband talked to her earlier in the day, but she never came home. The husband found McMurray deceased at the office when he went to check on her. Capt. Joel Shores of the Cleveland County Sheriff’s Office said McMurray died from a stab wound.
- Asha Degree Feb., 14, 2000
Degree was last seen by her father around 2:30 a.m. before he went to bed. Two motorists said they last saw Degree alive walking alongside N.C. 18, around one mile from the Degree home in Shelby. Her book bag was unearthed in Burke County by a man bulldozing property along N.C. 18. every year since Asha’s disappearance, family and friends walk along N.C. 18 on Valentine’s Day where she was last seen.
- Mouy Tang Sept. 3, 2008
Tang was 46 years old when she was last seen at Unique Living. a short time later, a Burns High teacher spotted her near the school. The Tang family announced in September 2009 that they believed she was dead. On may 9, 2011, her family was awarded $2 million in damages as a result of their civil suit against Unique Living for Mouy Tang’s disappearance.
What happens to a murder investigation when the crime scene disappears?
Gravel covers the patch of grass where a lifeless body once lay. Tips on possible suspects now lead to dead ends. Witnesses who gave statements have moved away. Some have died.
What does an investigator do next? Work around it. Find a connection. at the Cleveland County Sheriff’s Office. that job falls to two detectives and a special agent.
The Sheriff’s Office cold Case Unit formed in early 2011. Retired Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Detective Jim Hollingsworth works with Detective Jimmy West, who retired from the Gastonia Police Department, and N.C. State Bureau of Investigation Special Agent John Kaiser on the unit.
“what got these men to the table was their work ethic,” Norman said. “These families deserve closure.”
Ground truth
The earth sciences define “ground truth” as facts found when a location is field-checked; in other words, finding facts when visiting a location.
Hollingsworth uses the technique when investigating crimes.
“Some things aren’t obvious and you won’t get unless you physically go out there,” he said.
A patron found Charleen Simons, 49, dead inside The Log Cabin, her tavern and home. Then-sheriff Dan Crawford told The Star she died from stab wounds on June 21, 1995.
The Kings Mountain gaming tavern is gone. Now, a fenced-in business stands in its place.
Hollingsworth said in this case, the unit relies on previous sketches, maps and diagrams to reconstruct crime scenes. He drove to the place where the cabin once stood.
“once I see and feel it, it makes it easier,” Hollingsworth said. “I like to stand on that ground.”
Hollingsworth said he’ll drive different routes to a crime a scene. He’ll gauge how long it takes to arrive and leave a scene, trying to pinpoint a suspect’s route.
The murder of Charleen Simons was the first case solved by the unit this year.
The Sheriff’s Office charged three men, from Georgia, Tennessee and South Carolina, with murdering Simons.
From DNA to Facebook
Crimes happen every day, from robberies, assaults, to home break-ins.
An officer’s case load never ends. one case closes as another opens.
Time is the cold Case Unit’s advantage, West said, clutching a white sheet of paper. The words, typed in black letters, listed the nine open homicide and two missing person cases under the Sheriff’s Office’s jurisdiction.
The unsolved cases on the list are the only ones the unit investigates.
West said the unit feeds off of the original investigations to make progress.
“what I don’t see, Hollingsworth could catch (and vice versa),” West said.
Hollingsworth said since his career started in 1980, he’s amazed by the technological advances made with DNA connected to evidence.
“back then, for me to get good DNA, I would need an entire hair strand, a good amount of skin or blood,” he said. “Now, I need a molecule sample.”
The National DNA Database allows law enforcement to submit DNA from a crime scene to see if a registered offender matches the sample.
West called the database “huge” to solving cases, but finding a missing person presents its own obstacles.
“you have physical evidence at a crime scene, but with a missing person, you don’t have a starting point,” West said.
The cases of Asha Degree, who went missing at 9 years old in 2000, and Mouy Tang, who vanished in 2008, are still open.
West noted that social networking sites like Facebook are tools law enforcement can use to locate suspects and individuals reported missing.
“It’s harder to disappear; to live completely off the grid,” West said. “Technology allows us to find people that might have moved away or changed their names.”
Not like TV
An oval wooden table sits in a control room on the first floor of the Sheriff’s Office.
Here, West said, is where the unit examines the county’s cold cases for countless hours.
The cold Case Unit works part-time, sometimes more, Norman said.
West carried four thick notebooks into the room. Taped interview transcripts, suspect information, maps, sketches, lab reports and anything case-related are sealed in the binder’s slots.
West carried binders labeled “The Log Cabin.”
Only half of Simons’ case was in the binders.
“It’s more of an analytical process,” West said, explaining how the unit approaches each case. “We go through each case, suspect information, contact past investigators and look at lab reports.
West, Hollingsworth and Kaiser check each other’s work. what one doesn’t catch, another one can.
“a new set of eyes sees things differently,” West said. “We try to be objective and not get tunnel vision. It’s hard. When you focus on one thing, like a suspect or clue, you could miss something else.”
West said the team is unlikely to solve a case by the time one episode of “CSI” finishes.
“Some people have unreal expectations. TV is TV. Time is compressed,” West said. “It doesn’t happen that way in real life.”
Hollingsworth said the unit can’t promise to solve every case, but the detectives vow to give each 100 percent of their investigative efforts.
Detectives never close the books on a murder case — no matter how old — until it’s solved.
Reach reporter Alicia Banks at 704-669-3338.
See archived ‘Local News’ stories »